South Carolina Governor Henry McMaster has requested the state Supreme Court to reconsider its recent decision declaring the state’s school voucher program unconstitutional. The court had ruled that using taxpayer funds for private school tuition violates the state constitution, leaving many families in uncertainty just weeks into the school year.
The ruling halted $6,000 annual scholarships for low-income families, leading to concerns from parents who had relied on this support to cover private school tuition. McMaster argued that giving money to parents, who then choose where to allocate it, does not directly benefit private schools. Despite this, the court’s majority disagreed, calling this reasoning a mere attempt to sidestep the state’s constitutional restrictions.
While McMaster is pushing for a rehearing, legislative leaders are doubtful that a new hearing will lead to a different outcome. They have pledged to address the issue when the Legislature reconvenes in January, with a focus on restoring opportunities for affected students.
The voucher program had enrolled nearly 2,900 students, but it remains unclear how many were using the funds for private school tuition. Parents have been informed that they can continue receiving quarterly payments, but these funds can only be used for services like tutoring, textbooks, or public school tuition outside their district.
Parents like Brittany Almeida, who enrolled her child in private school under the program, now face uncertainty on how to continue covering tuition. Similarly, Maria Valenzuela, a mother of four, is unsure how to cover private school costs without the scholarships. Many parents are now considering alternative options, such as seeking additional jobs or exploring other financial assistance.
Schools are also feeling the impact. Divine Redeemer Catholic School, which enrolled 31 students under the voucher program, is struggling to find ways to keep those students enrolled. Fundraising efforts are underway, and the Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston has launched a relief fund to cover tuition shortfalls for students in its schools.
For many families and schools, the future remains uncertain as they await further action from the state.
